Where to Eat in St. Augustine: Restaurants, Coffee Shops, Pizza, and Drinks We Love

One of the things I enjoy most about visiting St. Augustine is walking around the historic district, discovering pretty streets, and eventually finding a place that catches our attention. If you’re wondering where to eat in St. Augustine, here are some restaurants, coffee shops, and bars we’ve tried on different visits and enjoyed enough to want to return to. I’m also including a few places that are still on our list, because as I always say, I never get tired of visiting this city!

Not every place on this list is a sit-down restaurant for a long dinner. Sometimes we just want a good cup of coffee, a slice of pizza while walking around midday, or a nice spot to enjoy a drink in the late afternoon. And St. Augustine has options for all of that.

Start Your Day Right

We often take day trips from Orlando, so we haven’t had the chance to try many breakfast or brunch spots. But here are a couple we’ve visited!

Nero’s Waterfront Cafe

Nero’s Waterfront Cafe is located at the Casablanca Inn, right along the water on Avenida Menendez. It’s one of those places that catches your eye because of its atmosphere and location, especially if you enjoy breakfast or brunch with waterfront views.

We went there for breakfast, and the experience was a little interesting. The place is really pretty, and we enjoyed the food, but the indoor area where we were seated was quite small. Let’s just say it wasn’t the most comfortable spot for sitting around and chatting for a long time, even though the food was good.

If you enjoy classic breakfast dishes and brunch favorites, this might be worth considering. They also have outdoor seating, so if the weather cooperates, it’s worth asking about availability. You may want to arrive early or keep in mind that you might have to wait a little if you’re hoping to get a table with a water view.

Coffee Is Always a Good Idea

The Kookaburra

If there’s one place I enjoy returning to for coffee in St. Augustine, it’s The Kookaburra.

It’s a great stop whether you want to sit down for a few minutes and enjoy your drink or grab something to go and continue exploring the city. I like having that flexibility because when we’re out sightseeing, we don’t always want to stop for too long, but we also don’t want to settle for just any coffee.

The Kookaburra has Australian-inspired roots and offers coffee drinks, lattes, teas, and a few pastry and light food options. If you enjoy trying different coffee flavors, take a look at their specialty drinks.

They also have several locations around St. Augustine. If you’re exploring the historic district, look for the Cathedral Place location to enjoy a little coffee break between walks.

St. Augustine Coffee House

I’ve stopped here a couple of times, especially during those day trips from Orlando. Before walking back to the parking area, I like to grab a little coffee for the road.

It’s a local, cozy spot with an outdoor seating area where you can enjoy your coffee alongside a delicious treat from their own bakery. Honestly, this is one of those places worth stopping by.

Lunch or Dinner

There are plenty of options in St. Augustine, but here are a few places we’ve tried where you can sit back, enjoy the atmosphere, and take your time with your meal.

Saint

Saint is one of those places we discovered while exploring the area, and we liked it so much that we decided to return on another visit.

The first time, we went for dinner and sat out on the patio. We loved it! The atmosphere was great, and it made for a really enjoyable evening. We liked it so much that we decided to come back another time, this time for lunch.

On our second visit, we chose to sit indoors because it was simply too hot to eat outside. The restaurant has beautiful decor, the service was excellent, and the food was delicious, just as it had been during our first visit a year earlier.

Saint serves Italian-inspired cuisine and cocktails, with options for different times of the day, including brunch on select days of the week. I think it’s a nice choice if you’re looking for something a little more special, whether for lunch or a pleasant dinner.

My advice is to keep the Florida heat in mind if you’re visiting on a warm day. Dining on the patio can be a very different experience from sitting indoors. And if you’re planning to visit during a popular dining time, check table availability or consider making a reservation ahead of time.

Prohibition Kitchen

During another visit to St. Augustine, we had lunch at Prohibition Kitchen, a place I found quite interesting because of its decor and atmosphere inspired by the Prohibition era in the United States.

I thought the food was good, and the restaurant definitely has its own personality, combining vintage details, a pub atmosphere, and live music. It’s located right on St. George Street, which makes it very convenient if you’re exploring the historic district on foot.

We returned another time, but on that visit, we just sat at the bar to enjoy a beer. I like places that work both for a full meal and for a quick stop to enjoy a drink without having to plan a whole night out.

If you enjoy live music, cocktails, and restaurants with a lively atmosphere, keep this one in mind during your visit.

A Quick Lunch or Snack

Pizza Time

Sometimes we don’t feel like sitting down for an hour to eat. We just want something tasty so we can keep walking and exploring the city.

That’s how we ended up grabbing a few slices of pizza at Pizza Time, right on St. George Street. And it was so good!

I think it’s a convenient option if you’re exploring this pedestrian-friendly street and feel like having something to eat without making a big production out of it. They serve Brooklyn-style pizza by the slice or as a whole pie, so you can grab just one slice and keep walking or order a full pizza if you’re with a group.

Plus, the location is perfect for a quick break while checking out the shops and historic buildings in the area.

Likit Soft Serve

And if you’re in the mood for something sweet while walking along St. George Street, this is a great option, especially on those hot summer afternoons!

Passport Sweets

A shop I absolutely love! Here you’ll find sweets, chocolates, cookies, and more from all over the world. I’ve spotted treats from Japan, Brazil, Germany, and even Venezuela.
It’s definitely worth stopping for a few minutes to try something different. It’s not right on St. George Street, but just a short walk away. Here’s the location on the map.

Cocktails and a Fun Atmosphere

The Tipsy Duck Parlor

If you’re looking for a fun place to try something different, The Tipsy Duck Parlor deserves a spot on your list.

Located inside Bath Junkie on Hypolita Street and has a pretty unusual theme: drinks with funny names, duck-inspired decor, and even seats that look like bathtubs. Definitely not the typical bar you’d expect to find while exploring a historic city.

It’s a fun option if you enjoy trying different cocktails and want to make a stop that’s also a little entertaining.

Since the drinks and the quirky concept are part of the experience, I’d recommend checking out the menu first to see what catches your eye.

Meehan’s Irish Pub

If you’re in the mood for a beer in an Irish pub atmosphere, Meehan’s Irish Pub is another good option.

We haven’t eaten there yet, so I can’t tell you about the food from personal experience, but the place looks inviting and its menu includes traditional Irish dishes, burgers, sandwiches, and seafood options.

One of its advantages is the location along the waterfront, near Castillo de San Marcos. It also has different seating areas, including spots with water views.

This one is still on our list for a future visit, hopefully to try something from the menu and tell you more about it!

Restaurants Still on Our List

Columbia Restaurant

Although we haven’t eaten at the Columbia location in St. Augustine yet, I’ve visited other restaurants from this chain, so I have high expectations for when we finally make it there.

The St. Augustine restaurant is located at the corner of St. George Street and Hypolita Street, right in the historic district. Its menu is inspired by Spanish and Cuban cuisine, with dishes such as paella, arroz con pollo, black beans and rice, along with sangria and mojitos.

And here’s an interesting bit of history: Columbia’s story began in Tampa, when Casimiro Hernandez Sr. opened the Columbia Saloon in 1903. The establishment was renamed Columbia Restaurant in 1905 and eventually became one of Florida’s best-known historic restaurants.

So even though I haven’t tried the St. Augustine location yet, I’d love to visit on a future getaway.

Cap’s on the Water

Although it’s not in the historic district but rather in the Vilano Beach area, Cap’s on the Water looks like an interesting option for a meal by the water. It’s located along the Intracoastal Waterway and serves seafood, Southern-inspired dishes, and cocktails.

With its waterfront location and outdoor seating areas, it seems like a great place to enjoy a relaxed meal. And if the timing and weather work out, you might even catch the sunset!

Aunt Kate’s Restaurant

Also in the Vilano Beach area, Aunt Kate’s Restaurant is another place we still have on our list. It’s right along the Tolomato River and has a traditional Florida atmosphere, with trees, water views, and seafood options.

I’m especially interested in the possibility of dining on the outdoor deck while watching the boats go by. Its menu also includes seafood dishes and some specialties influenced by Minorcan cuisine, a culinary tradition connected to the history of this part of Florida.

Nonna’s Trattoria

Every time we walk along Aviles Street, one of the oldest historic streets in St. Augustine, I notice Nonna’s Trattoria and get curious about it.

We’ve often seen it quite busy, which always makes us think we should plan ahead and make a reservation on our next visit. It’s a family-owned Italian restaurant serving classic dishes in what looks like a lovely setting for a relaxed dinner.

It’s also located on a street that’s worth exploring for its art galleries and historic atmosphere, so it could be a nice addition to a future evening out.

Tips for Eating in St. Augustine

One of the things I love about St. Augustine is that I don’t think you need to plan every little detail of your visit. Of course, there are restaurants where making a reservation is a good idea, especially on weekends, holidays, or during busy travel seasons. But it’s also nice to leave some room to discover places along the way.

Here are a few tips that have worked well for us:

Walk along St. George Street and the nearby streets. Don’t limit yourself to looking up restaurants before you arrive. Sometimes a place catches your eye because of its decor, the menu posted outside, or simply because you see other people enjoying their food.

Explore beyond St. George Street. Streets like Aviles Street and the Avenida Menendez area also have restaurants, bars, and coffee shops worth discovering.

Make food part of your sightseeing plans. You can grab coffee in the morning, enjoy a quick lunch, continue visiting historic sites, and finish the day with dinner or a cocktail.

Keep Florida’s heat in mind. If you’d like to sit on a patio or outdoor deck, check the weather forecast. During the hotter months, indoor seating may be much more comfortable.

Check opening hours before heading out. Opening days, service hours, and menus can change. If you have a specific restaurant in mind, check its official website before visiting.

What Are Your Favorite Restaurants in St. Augustine?

As you can see, we’ve tried a little bit of everything: from coffee and pizza by the slice to patio dinners and a few beers at the bar. And we still have plenty of places left to discover!

One of the reasons I enjoy returning to St. Augustine so much is that every visit can be different. We might start the day planning to visit a historic site and end up discovering a restaurant we didn’t know about, or return to a place we enjoyed on a previous trip.

Now I’d love to hear from you: What restaurants, coffee shops, or bars do you recommend in St. Augustine? Is there a place you always visit when you’re in town? Share your recommendations in the comments because I want to start putting together our list for the next getaway.

And just like that, we’ll have one more excuse to come back!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *